Showing posts with label Disney. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Disney. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Disney Tracery


Wow. Just saw this video, demonstrating how many bits of classic Disney animation have been recycled over the years. Not just conceptual re-use of old jokes: we're talking about literal, frame-by-frame recreations of animated movement. See Baloo become Little John! Watch Snow White transform instantly into Maid Marian! It appears the animators literally pulled whole blocks of animation out of the archives and re-traced it with the new characters in place of the old ones. Kind of a Luddite's Search and Replace. 

What's interesting -- and, I suppose, somewhat reassuring -- is that virtually all of the "theft" comes from the lamest period in Disney's history: the doldrums from 1967-1984, between the death of Walt Disney and the arrival of Eisner/Wells/Katzenberg, when the studio was being run by Walt's son-in-law. It's the period that gave us "Robin Hood" and "The Aristocats," perhaps the worst two Disney animated films ever, and the biggest ani-theft culprits in this video. 

Looks like what may have started as a benign way to quickly fill gaps in an animated sequence devolved into all-out self-plagiarism for a while there. The Bleak Years were characterized by a drought of creativity on all fronts, and it's not surprising that the animation itself suffered along with the terrible story, music, editing and character design of the period. I don't think you'd see anything like this from "The Little Mermaid" forward. The example from "Beauty and the Beast," in which Belle and Beast's waltz steps are shown to be similar to Aurora's from "Sleeping Beauty," really falls more under the heading of homage rather than chicanery. 

The lesson: don't steal, kids. It may take forty years, but the truth will out.

UPDATE: KMS informs me that she saw this video a month ago. It was posted, naturally, by the accursed Dave Cobb. So the second lesson is: don't be the second guy to post. 

Wow. Just saw this video, demonstrating how many bits of classic Disney animation have been recycled over the years. Not just conceptual re-use of old jokes: we're talking about literal, frame-by-frame recreations of animated movement. See Baloo become Little John! Watch Snow White transform instantly into Maid Marian! It appears the animators literally pulled whole blocks of animation out of the archives and re-traced it with the new characters in place of the old ones. Kind of a Luddite's Search and Replace.

What's interesting -- and, I suppose, somewhat reassuring -- is that virtually all of the "theft" comes from the lamest period in Disney's history: the doldrums from 1967-1984, between the death of Walt Disney and the arrival of Eisner/Wells/Katzenberg, when the studio was being run by Walt's son-in-law. It's the period that gave us "Robin Hood" and "The Aristocats," perhaps the worst two Disney animated films ever, and the biggest ani-theft culprits in this video. 

Looks like what may have started as a benign way to quickly fill gaps in an animated sequence devolved into all-out self-plagiarism for a while there. The Bleak Years were characterized by a drought of creativity on all fronts, and it's not surprising that the animation itself suffered along with the terrible story, music, editing and character design of the period. I don't think you'd see anything like this from "The Little Mermaid" forward. The example from "Beauty and the Beast," in which Belle and Beast's waltz steps are shown to be similar to Aurora's from "Sleeping Beauty," really falls more under the heading of homage rather than chicanery. 

The lesson: don't steal, kids. The truth will out, even if it takes forty years.

UPDATE: KMS informs me that she saw this video a month ago. It was posted, naturally, by the accursed Dave Cobb. New lesson: never try to out-Cobb Cobb.